Rob and Tim met on the Longue View Country Club swim team when both boys were 8. Their mothers Joyce and Beth sat next to each other in the bleachers during the Pittsburgh summer's swim practices, watching their boys learn freestyle, backstroke, breaststroke, and butterfly. The boys always swam in adjacent lanes. One year, they were the last to go in the lane. The next year, they each moved up a place in the lane. When they started winning first places in the various events (Rob in the 100 meter backstroke, Tim in the 100 meter butterfly), they moved to first position in their lanes, leading off the team.
Rob's family lived in Monroeville, so Rob joined the high school swim team when he entered 9th grade. Tim's family lived in nearby Penn Hills, so he joined that high school team at the same time. Both boys fell right back to the bottom of the totem pole as they each competed with boys older than they. Joyce and Beth, good swim mothers, pushed their sons to work hard at practice. Joyce sat in the swimming pool bleachers in Monroeville's high school, Beth sat in the bleachers at Penn Hills's high school. They gave their boys an added advantage by joining private all-year swim clubs. Rob went to Greater Pittsburgh Swim Club. Tim went to the Jewish Y.
Rob began to concentrate more on long-distance swimming, competing in high school meets in third position for the team. Tim did exactly the same. Rob began to win first and second place ribbons at meets. So did Tim. In their sophomore year, Monroeville won the division championship. In their junior year, Penn Hills won the championship. When Rob and Tim came near the end of their senior year, Monroeville and Penn Hills tied in the lead for that year's championship.
By tradition, coaches gave seniors first choice of events for the final meets of the season. When Monroeville and Penn Hills met, Rob chose the 500 yard freestyle -- his best long-distance event. Tim chose the 500 yard freestyle -- his best long-distance event. The two teams met on a cold February night. Penn Hills hosted. Joyce and Beth attended, sitting on opposite ends of the bleachers. Rob approached Lane 3 for the big event. Tim approached Lane 4 for the big event. They shook hands, mounted the platform, on your mark, get set, bang! went the gun.
20 laps of the 25 yard pool. Rob and Tim swam neck and neck for the first 4. Joyce and Beth stood up in the bleachers, cheering on their sons. Then Rob took the lead for another 6, swimming 4 yards ahead of Tim. Joyce jumped up and down. Then Rob slowed down and Tim took the lead for another 6, swimming 2 yards ahead of Rob. Beth jumped up and down. On laps 17 and 18, Rob caught up to Tim. On laps 19 and 20, Rob pulled ahead of Tim and touched the wall just 0.75 seconds before Tim. Joyce cheered, waved her hands while Beth scowled, sat down on her hands.
The Monroeville team cheered while the Penn Hills team booed. Both boys got out of the water. Rob shook Tim's hand. Excited but exhausted, Rob jumped back in the water. The Penn Hills referee blew his whistle, voiding Rob and declaring Tim the winner. Rules said, swimmers couldn't get back in the water after getting out.
Joyce and Beth quit the social circles to which both belonged. Rob went to Ohio State for college. Tim went to Columbia. They never saw each other again.